Blog

How to move from Fastmail without losing a message

The order that keeps every message: a Fastmail app password, the IMAP copy, what does not transfer, the MX swap, and when it is safe to cancel. With Fastmail's current prices.

Ethan SchwartzUpdated 17 November 20266 min read

Fastmail makes some of the best mail apps there are, and if you are one person who lives in email you may be right to stay. If you are leaving because the per-user bill grew with the team, here is the order of operations that loses nothing.

Why people leave, and who should not

The reason is almost always the meter. On fastmail.com/pricing, checked 6 October 2026, Business Standard, the plan with custom domains and IMAP, is $6 per user a month, or $5 on annual billing ($60 a year per user). An Individual plan is the same $6 or $5 with 60 GB. For one person that is a fair price for excellent apps. For six people on one domain it is $360 a year, and the seventh hire adds another $60. Faivelo Starter is $6 a month for the whole domain, however many mailboxes it has.

So the honest sorting: if you are one person, your whole working life is in the Fastmail app, and you use Masked Email every day, stay. The move below is for a team, or for someone whose inbox is just an inbox.

The order of operations

  1. Make the app password. Fastmail does not let a third-party tool use your normal login. Go to Settings, Privacy & Security, Connected apps & API tokens, then Manage app passwords and access (fastmail.help, App passwords, checked 6 October 2026). Name it after the new host, keep the default Mail, Contacts & Calendars access, click Generate password and copy it, because the page shows it once.
  2. Set up the destination first. Add the domain at the new host and create the mailboxes with the same local parts (anna@, support@). Leave DNS alone for now; Fastmail must keep receiving until the copy is done.
  3. Copy over IMAP. Faivelo's migration tool has a Fastmail preset: enter the address and the app password, run the free connection test to see folder counts and size, then start the copy. It runs in the background, reads only, and preserves folders, read state and dates. Trash and Spam are skipped unless you ask for them.
  4. Export the rest. Calendars and contacts are not mail. Export them from Fastmail as .ics and .vcf files and import them at the new host, or let the migration tool copy them where it supports it. Masked Email addresses are Fastmail-owned addresses, and @fastmail.com aliases are on Fastmail's domain: both stop working when the account closes, so switch any logins that use them to an address on your own domain first.
  5. Swap the records. At your registrar, replace the Fastmail MX records with the new host's and update the SPF, DKIM and DMARC TXT records. At a supported registrar Faivelo writes these for you; elsewhere you paste them from the dashboard. Within minutes to an hour, new mail arrives at the new host. Fastmail still holds everything received up to that moment.
  6. Final copy, then cancel. Run the copy once more to pick up anything that landed during the swap, compare message counts, and then cancel the Fastmail subscription. Cancel before the renewal date, not after; Fastmail bills per user, so a forgotten account is a forgotten seat.

What does not transfer, in one place

Masked Email addresses, @fastmail.com aliases, and any @fastmail.fm or other Fastmail-domain address: these belong to Fastmail and end with the account. Labels become folders, which is how IMAP sees them. Rules and filters are rebuilt at the new host; Faivelo has its own rules in webmail. Snoozed messages come across as ordinary mail. Calendars and contacts move as files, not as part of the mail copy.

Everything on your own domain survives. That is the point of owning the domain: the address is yours, the host is a tenant.

The address is yours. The host is a tenant.

What it costs after

Faivelo Starter is $6 a month flat with 10 GB pooled and up to three domains; Growth is $12 with 200 GB, unlimited domains and a calendar. Mailboxes and aliases are unlimited on both, and a catch-all is included. Every mailbox works in Apple Mail, Outlook and Thunderbird over IMAP and SMTP, as it did at Fastmail. The feature-by-feature table, including where Fastmail still comes out ahead, is on the Fastmail comparison page.

FAQs

Will I lose mail during the MX swap?

No. Mail in flight goes to whichever host the sending server resolves at that moment, and both are live. The final copy after the swap picks up anything that landed at Fastmail late.

Does Fastmail delete my mail when I cancel?

Fastmail's own terms govern retention after closure; do not rely on it. Finish the copy and confirm the counts before you cancel.

Can I keep my Fastmail aliases?

Aliases on your own domain move with the domain; recreate them at the new host. Aliases on Fastmail's domains and Masked Email addresses cannot be moved.

How long does the copy take?

It depends on size. A few gigabytes usually finish within the hour; the tool keeps running if you close the page.

Found this useful? Share it.

Copy first, swap second, cancel last

Start a trial, add your domain, paste the Fastmail app password into the migration tool, and watch the folders arrive. Fourteen days, no card, and Fastmail keeps working until you change the MX records.

Start freeFree 14-day trial. No card needed.

Keep reading